Historic stays in Mid-Atlantic

Stone taverns of the Pennsylvania turnpikes, Hudson Valley and Catskill resorts, and Gilded Age estates turned inns. 12 buildings in 4 states; 9 were confirmed taking guests when we checked.

Confirmed taking guests (checked by hand) Historic building with a lodging history

Built between 1758 and 1922. Most common style here: Georgian and Colonial (2).

New York 7

Bear Mountain Inn

Bear Mountain (Stony Point), New York

Built 1914–1915 · Rustic (Parkitecture)

Takes guests · checked 2026-10-26

Beaverkill Valley Inn

Lew Beach (Hardenburgh), New York

Built 1895 · Queen Anne

Takes guests · checked 2026-10-26

Mohonk Mountain House

New Paltz, New York

Built 1869–1902 (oldest surviving part 1879) · Queen Anne

Takes guests · checked 2026-10-26

Oheka Castle

Cold Spring Hills (Huntington), New York

Built 1914–1919 · Neoclassical and Beaux-Arts

Takes guests · checked 2026-10-26

Rogues' Harbor Inn

Lansing (South Lansing), New York

Built 1830–1842 · Greek Revival

Takes guests · checked 2026-10-26

The Sagamore

Bolton Landing (Bolton), New York

Built 1922–1930 (third hotel on the site; first opened 1883) · Colonial Revival

Takes guests · checked 2026-10-26

Wiawaka Holiday House

Lake George, New York

Built c. 1873–1912 · Second Empire

Takes guests · checked 2026-10-26

New Jersey 1

Lambertville House

Lambertville, New Jersey

Built 1812; Italianate enlargement c. 1865–1875 · Federal (Adam)

Takes guests · checked 2026-10-26

Pennsylvania 3

Buhl Mansion

Sharon, Pennsylvania

Built 1891 · Romanesque Revival

Takes guests · checked 2026-10-26

Jean Bonnet Tavern

Napier Township (near Bedford), Pennsylvania

Built c. 1762–1779 · Georgian and Colonial

Lodging history

Sun Inn

Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

Built 1758–1760; enlarged 1826 and 1850s; restored after 1971 · Georgian and Colonial

Lodging history

Delaware 1

Deer Park Tavern

Newark, Delaware

Built 1851; wings later 19th century · Greek Revival

Lodging history